X

>

Hyper Femininity in the Trans Community

June 13, 2011 by Sera Wohldmann   Comments (2)

, ,

Today's post may upset a few people, but please finish reading before blasting me too hard. As always, comments of any kind are always welcome.

Perhaps I'm standing in a strange spot, here. Perhaps my perspective is a little off - or even a lot off. But there's one thing I've noticed among transgender/transsexual women is something I've called, for the time being, Hyper Femininity. Let me explain, ladies.

Scenario: You just came home after a long day (or in cases like mine, night) of work, and all you want to do is get out of those damn clothes and have fun (disregarding for this scenario whether or not you're even out or dressing at work, doesn't apply here). But, it looks like none of your favorite hangouts are open, and you have some shopping and errands to do. Damn responsibility... *angrily shakes fist at empty space*

So you walk over to the closet and think about where you're going and what you're doing. Nothing glamourous, that's for sure. Do you grab some jeans and a simple top or T-shirt? I know I do. The Trans Hyper Feminine, however, due to reasons I cannot explain, grabs a nice dress or skirt. Like, with a very bright pattern, a full accessory spread, and plenty of stone/sequins works on it. What gives?

Are we so insecure in ourselves and our womanhood that we have to overcompensate? Is there something masculine or butch about slacks or jeans? Let's face it, they're a lot easier to deal with, especially if you have your hands full on a windy day! So where's the shame?

It's something I've seen time and again, and I don't know why. Believe me, I'm not a skirt-hater or anything; I wear one on stage all the time. But let's be realistic; most cis women would grab the T-shirt to get this job done. It just makes sense. Cis women don't feel the need to overcompensate for something like that; what makes trans women different?

I've even been attacked by trans women for wearing jeans to a trans club! You would think this is a joke, but this has happened many times. Suddenly I'm not as authentic, not "trans" enough (whatever the fuck that means) or not trying hard enough...even though this particular club is held in a dive bar, a place where, if it were not a trans club, would make me look ridiculous.

Perhaps I'm missing the point altogether. Maybe it's just me, I'm not qualified to speak because of my casual/soft-butch-with-hair identity. I don't know. Maybe someone can enlighten me? What's the appeal in looking ridiculously over-made-up for the situation?

Note: I know that I have trans men reading this as well, but I chose not to cover that side because I, in my limited experiences with trans men, have not seen the inverse (hyper masculinity) be even noticeable among the guys. Again, if I'm wrong in that department, feel free to let me know.

I registered an account just to reply to this.

"Hyper-femininty" is a term relative to your own experience, your own opinions. You are dictating what you believe is "normal behavior", yet I understand from my travels that  some cis-women exhibit the same traits you are attributing to some trans-women. There is not really "normal" dressing behavior, we all do what we feel is normal, what is comfortable to us.

I do however understand the point you are trying to make, and I myself and not one of these people you describe. I often go out in jeans, without make-up, but that is because I am ok with people confusing my gender. I understand that some trans people feel they need to work a lot harder on their image to get the desired effect of achieving the appearance of their preferred gender, and I also understand that some peopel just enjoy exhibiting "hyper-feminity". I know that when the moment presents itself (not often, admittedly) I would like to take advantage of it.

I don't think it HAS to do with insecurity, though some may feel that way. I don't think it's appropriate or useful to paint this sect of the community with such a broad brush, accusing hyper-feminine trans people as insecure. I find that somewhat offensive and naive.

How are jeans and t-shirts more "realistic" than anything else? That, too, is simply a conformity to a mainstream percieved sense of practicality. There is no rule deciding for us what is really practical or stating that we are to conform to such a standard.

I think your experience with aggressive club-going fashionistas is interesting, and while I am unable to form any conclusions based on my limited knowledge of your encounter, I urge you to objectively ask yourself why that encounter may have transpired. Were they just rabid, did they have a valid reason to confront you (in your mind or theirs), did the encounter leave you with a bias towards people whom choose to not dress practically?

To answer this question:
 "What's the appeal in looking ridiculously over-made-up for the situation?"

I think perhaps you are unfairly judging those of us whom do not feel it is ridiculous to dress in this manner despite what the occasion may be. These are just opinions, not hard facts, and are subject to our individual experiences, beliefs, and percpetions.

Ash 237 days ago